I have always taken things too seriously. Thank Goodness.
There was a Matthew in every one of my six English classes. The Matthews chose to slump away from their desks and looked physically uncomfortable in their seats- a metaphor for how they felt about life. One particular Matthew would enter class, on time, hidden under the hood of his jacket, tuned out but tuned in to his Ipod. When class started I would catch his attention, smile and motion for him to take out his earphones. He always complied. When I taught, he never looked my way. His attendance was perfect though he didn’t do the assignments. He never interrupted and he never caused a problem. Once in a while, he would look at me but when I looked back he retreated like a turtle into his shell. He tried very hard to stay disconnected, but not hard enough.
One day, for no apparent reason (hindsight would clarify this), I told the class a story about a college friend of mine whose name was David. One evening, David went out to the garage where he kept his 1970 Chevy Impala. The car was a gift from his grandfather and was so valuable that David couldn’t afford the insurance. Consequently, he drove the car infrequently, only for special occasions or an occasional date. When David opened the garage where the car was stored over the summer, he was surprised to find it empty. David promptly called his friends and a brother to inquire if someone had borrowed the Impala without asking. No one had. David called the police and was told that a band of car thieves had traveled through town on a thieving rampage.
A month later, David came to French class excited to tell the rest of the story. A man employed by the BLM, found the Impala dumped on government land. It was beat up, but he asked his boss if he could have the car to fix up and see if it worked. The boss said “sure.”
The man had the car re-keyed and detailed. He bought a new battery, had the upholstery fixed, bought new hubcaps and did a few other fix-ups.
As I retold David’s story to my tenth grade English class, I noticed that Matthew was listening to and looking at me. He was engaged for the first time since class had started. I finished the story with the BLM employee going to the DMV to register his fabulous find. But, the car came up STOLEN. My friend David got his car back in better condition than when he owned it.
A few days later, Matthew looked up and asked, “Do you have any more car stories?”
“I don’t Matthew, but I’ll try to find one. You must love cars.” That day Matthew told me about the cars that he and his father had restored. He told me about the car his mother ruined. By week three, Matthew was coming early into class and putting his backpack in a chair to save his place. The hood on his sweatshirt rested on his back, he engaged in and offered insight into the discussions. He told me he didn’t need to look up the vocabulary words because he already knew what they meant. I doubted him, so we walked through the words together and he was able to give me a definition for nine of the ten words. He was revealing his intelligence. By week four, Matthew was coming early to class to finish his lunch. Matt became a friend.
The previous weeks of class were spent reading Rodman Philbrick’s Freak the Mighty. Each student was required to keep a workbook of their own making with details of the book: Chapter synopsis, main characters, settings, vocabulary, descriptions and character changes. I also asked them to keep a page or chart on themselves, three columns labeled: characteristics, experiences and changes. I explained that a component of Good literature is character change. Life is like good literature.
My fourth week of teaching, I asked the students to write a one page journal write, explaining the details of the chart they kept on themselves. It was simple, write about your characteristics and what events or experiences that made you change. Matt raised his hand and asked, “What if it’s too personal?” I wanted this to be a growing experience, so I gave students the option of showing me their work without turning it in. Matt lowered his eyes and started to write. About half-way through the fifteen minute writing exercise, he told me that he’d changed his mind and he wanted me to read his paper. By the time he’d finished he had decided that he wanted me to read his paper to the whole class because it would help them understand why he acted the way he did.
I took the papers home for the weekend. Every time I walked past my briefcase, I winced. What terrible things would Matt reveal? What would explain his laissez-faire attitude towards life? Saturday evening I bolstered the courage to read Matt’s paper. Matt wrote, When I was seven or eight years old, I was accused of molesting other children. I was almost taken out of my home and put in foster care. THIS IS WHY I HATE ALL PEOPLE. For the rest of the weekend I worried about Matt.
My final week. Matt came to class early. I handed him the letter I had written to him (enclosed), expressed my sorrow for the hurt he endured as a child, gave him my explanation for not reading his paper to the class and presented the best plan I could create for him as his English teacher. I wanted him to think about the difference between a wound and a scar. He started to explain the difference when I interrupted him and told him he was to think about it for the next two days. His next class period, I wanted him to journal write the difference between a wound and a scar. He was silent and then sweetly agreed to the task.
Last day of class. The students were writing a book review for Freak the Mighty. Matt and I acknowledged with a nod of the head that his assignment was different. Five minutes into the assignment, Matt called out to me, “You’re going to like this.”
With ten minutes left of class, the students had finished their assignment. There was a party atmosphere for my last day. Matt reminded me, “I think you’re really going to like what I’ve written.” He paused, “What should I do with my other paper? Should I burn it?”
The magnitude of what he said caused me to pause and think. And then I said, “Matt you can keep it or you can burn it, but if you burn it, make it a ritual, a letting go. Do you know what I mean?”
Matt nodded his head. “Yes, I know what you mean.”
I stayed after school that day to finish grading and recording the student’s work. I wanted to be completely finished with my five weeks. I had done my best and I didn’t want to hang on to what I was losing. I was sad that I could no longer show my enthusiasm for the beauty and power of words to high school students who stayed up too late over the weekend. I would miss the students, their original metaphors, their complaints about Huckleberry Finn, and the look in their eyes when they thought in a different way. I would miss their growth and their failures. Most of all I would miss the possibilities of change and discovery that came from thinking through and writing words. As I evaluated my objective, ‘five weeks to save their souls,’ I laughed at my crusade mentality. I couldn’t save their souls-- but I could provide an environment and some tools so hopefully, they could save themselves.